The Biggest Midterm Win that No One Is Talking About
Something happened in Montana that may change politics forever.
One of - if not the - most important stories of this election is barely getting any attention. And it might finally mean getting money out of politics for good.
Here’s the quick background. In 2010, the Supreme Court decided Citizens United, ruling that the government can’t ban corporations from spending money on elections because that would violate the First Amendment. As a result, over the last 16 years, corporate contributions to outside groups in federal elections have surged from $13 million to more than $600 million this year. Corporations and moneyed interests are outright buying our democracy– and it’s completely legal.
Enter: Montana. On November 3rd, roughly 65% of Montana voters approved Initiative 194, known as “The Montana Plan.” The Montana Plan codifies a simple legal idea: that a corporation isn’t a person. The authors of the initiative recognized that Citizens United never said a state has to give a corporation the power to spend money in politics. So the Montana Plan takes back every power the state has granted to corporations, and then re-grants only the ones needed to run a business. Political spending is not one of them. Corporations can still do business; they just can’t buy elections. The initiative applies to corporations, nonprofits, and other artificial entities, and it goes into effect on January 1.
Ironically enough, Montana has been a leader in this realm— or at least a different iteration of it. In 1912, Montana voters passed a citizen initiative banning corporate spending in candidate elections, with 76% of the vote, after copper barons were bribing legislators and dominating the state’s politics. So this isn’t new for Montana; it’s a century-old idea whose time has come again.
So what was the Republican response? I hope you’re sitting down for this: they sued to block it. The Montana Republican State Central Committee, along with the Frontier Institute, the Montana Family Foundation, and other conservative groups, filed their federal lawsuit in Helena at 11:15 PM on election night, 18 minutes before the race was even called. They didn’t even wait for the final count. And I think that tells you everything you need to know about whose interests they’re protecting— and the speed with which they’re protecting them.
Their argument is that the ban violates the First Amendment’s protections for free speech, assembly, and the press. Because, after all, how could we possibly protect the First Amendment without hundreds of millions of dollars drowning out the voices of regular Americans?
If Republicans want to die on the hill of demanding that corporations can spend millions to prop up their party - if that’s the side of this 90/10 issue on which they want to position themselves - that’s their prerogative. But at a moment of national realignment, largely on the issue of corruption and money in politics, I imagine Republicans are going to have a tough time convincing Americans that, actually, it’s a good thing when billionaires buy our elections.
Importantly, this doesn’t end in Montana. The group behind the initiative expects this case to reach the Supreme Court. If the Montana Plan survives, it becomes a blueprint any other state with the initiative process can use or any state legislature that recognizes the virtue in getting money out of politics can follow. That’s what the other side is afraid of. This isn’t about one state; it’s about whether the voters of any state can decide that elections are for people, not corporations.
We have been convinced that this is just something we have to accept. I reject that premise wholeheartedly. We can and we must get money out of politics. Montana just did it, with 65% of the vote, in a state Trump won by 20 points only two years ago. Which means that the only thing standing between us and getting it done is the will to try.
Here’s my promise to you: I will continue to doggedly highlight this issue. I am currently scheduling interviews with Montana officials, with those organizing against Citizens United, and with attorneys who will fight these battles in court. If getting money out of politics is important to you, please subscribe to support this newsletter as we work to make this a reality.

Way to go! Montana! And thank you so much for reporting on this! My dog and cat are closer to realistically being considered a “legal person!” They both have a heart, a brain and a conscience! !
Corporations are not people and should not be considered as such for taxation purposes or any other legislation.